Just like Grandma used to make! These old-fashioned peanut butter cookies are packed with flavor and pair perfectly with a cold glass of milk. Just the right amount of sweetness accompanies the full peanut taste, while the crisscross-marked tops will take you back to a simpler time. A true comfort food and a classic favorite, this is one of the best home-baked goodies to reach for when you have a hearty appetite for cookies with plenty of substance. You’ll want to eat every last tender crumb.
Generous size
Each cookie is about 3.5″ wide and 2 oz.
Pricing
Sold by the dozen (unless purchased at my bake stand)
Price per cookie: $2
Price per dozen: $24
Shipping
1-3 day UPS or USPS Priority:
$12 for one dozen
plus $3 for each additional dozen after that.
Local pickup
If you live in the Waukesha, WI, area, sign up to be notified when these are available at my little outdoor bake stand. Or order now and schedule a free pickup from my home bakery on Dale Dr. in Waukesha.
For ultimate freshness, cookies are made to order—I don’t bake until you buy.
Ingredients: Unbleached all-purpose flour, real butter, peanut butter (peanuts, sugar, palm oil, salt), granulated sugar, brown sugar, egg, pure vanilla extract, aluminum-free baking powder, baking soda, sea salt.
Allergen Disclaimer: These cookies are made in the same home kitchen as other baked goods, including ones with tree nuts. Therefore, cookies may contain common food allergens, such as milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, or wheat.